Did He Cheat On Her?
Emily made numerous attempts to persuade herself that David had no intention of cheating on her. Since the very beginning, they had never wavered in their commitment to one another, and she never once had any reason to question his sincerity. If he had a child from a previous relationship, there is no question that he would have disclosed this information to her, right?
Having Doubts
Even though Emily still didn’t want to accept it, the more she gave it more thought, the more sense it made. Furthermore, she was at a loss as to why Sophie would love David so much more yet feel nothing at all for Emily. What if he was her biological father? But… How can that account for their birthmarks?